L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner, Waterproof and Smudge-Resistant, Glides on Easily to Create any Look, Aubergine, 0.042 oz.

I love L'Oreal products and this eyeliner is one of the reasons! Smooth on, lasts well and color is clear.

I disliked it because every time it needed sharpened, I never got a point on the pencil. It would break off and very difficult to sharpen! Never had that problem before!

This is the color I was looking for, but it needs to be sharpened at every use and doesn't get sharp enough. Halfway down the pencil it wont even sharpen it just starting breaking. Not sure if I'll buy this again, unless they improve it. I hope they do.

Pretty colorEasy to apply and sharpenLasts all dayGreat value

I love this eyeliner pencil.

Pencil works beautifully-until it needs sharpening. It’s practically impossible to get a useable point on these pencils. It will not turn smoothly and evenly in the sharpener. The plastic comes off in chunks, leaving sharp edges and not enough exposed pencil to apply. Too expensive for something to that ends up being disposable.

Gorgeous color, long lasting, but easy to smudge. I’m a True Summer and this color works exceptionally well with all my taupes, grays & plum eye shadows.

Impossible to sharpen these when needed, so the entire pencil is worthless after you use the initial tip. It just constantly breaks off while trying to sharpen and leaves a very jagged edge which is harmful to your eyes. Will never purchase again.

This pencil is basically single use. Colour is nice, glide is nice, until you’ve used the initial tip. When it’s time to sharpen it (I attempted with 3 different types of sharpeners) the nice tip that I like to use breaks off, leaving me with a nub, edged by the sharp wood around it. We all have experienced the scratchy feeling when the pencil tip is too short. Never again will I buy this. Twist ups only from now on.

This goes on smooth and stays put. The colour is beautiful particularly if you have blue or green eyes!

This is my go to eyeliner because it lasts all day without smudging. Only drawback is that I have to sharpen it every time I use it because it’s very soft so doesn’t last as long. Given the reasonable price I just order It more often. I also wish it came in more colours as I’m not a fan of black or brown eyeliner, mostly I use the aubergine.

Nice color but smudged said waterproof I don beleive so smudged badly

Very good, def, stays put. Use it to waterline and it doesn't spread, which is awesome. My only issue is that after one use it needs sharpening again, so the pencil won't last long. And sharpening isn't easy. Otherwise happy with purchase.