Jersey Pickles - Sour Pickled Tomatoes (Gallon) – Pickled Vegetable – Handcrafted Gourmet Tomatoes for Sandwiches, Charcuterie & More

Delicious! Package arrived in great condition. Tomatoes have the perfect crunch, the size of the tomatoes were impressive and fresh!

My new favorite pickled item! Super crunchy and perfect amount of sour! 💕

SOOOOOOO SALTY!! And I love salt. But it was still too salty. Def not sour at all.

So good! Very crunchy and juicy. Great snack!

Will order again the tomatoes where very good! My only complaint is that the jar was leaking a little bit. Please try and work on sealing the jar better to avoid leaks. Other than that, everything else was great!

I’m writing this review because, at this point, it feels like I’m trying to catch the dragon. I ordered the sour tomatoes a couple of months ago, and they were an absolute 10/10—delicious, crunchy, and everything I hoped for. Well, I’ve tried to order them three more times since then… and every time, it’s been a disaster. The first attempt? The tomatoes arrived warm, soggy, and soft. I’m not sure what was happening there, but it wasn’t what I was hoping for. The second attempt was even worse: they arrived leaking and damaged, and I couldn’t even risk eating them due to concerns with food safety. By the third attempt, I thought, “Let’s go big or go home” and ordered a gallon of sour tomatoes. Big mistake. The tomatoes arrived leaking through the box, and someone had decided to "fix" the broken seal by slapping on some shipping tape (because that’s totally how you want your food sealed, right?). And since there are no refunds, I’m now stuck with $50 worth of green tomatoes I can’t even eat. Jersey Pickles, I really want to love you, but at this point, you’re making it rather difficult.

Loved every bite!

Was very excited as I love pickled green tomatoes/ tomatillos. These had an awful, almost chemical flavor to them. They are also very hard/crisp ifbyou like them that way. Texture is less important to me than taste. Tossed these sadly.