Mally BeautyEvercolor Starlight Waterproof Eyeliner - Grey Violet - Smudge-Proof, Longwear, Creamy Gel - Sharpenable Eyeliner

This is the BEST eyeliner I have ever had! It was originally given to me as a gift. Since then I have reordered this Mally stick. It has staying power and the color does not fade or easily come off! It is easy to apply and is forgiving of mistakes.

This eyeliner glides on smooth as silk without barely applying pressure. Best eyeliner I have ever used and I've been wearing eyeliner since 1972. Great value for the price as well. Thank you Mally!!!

Great eyeliner. It stays on and doesn't burn my eyes.

I love this stuff. It's bullet-proof (lasts all day).

The first time I got this product, it didn't smudge. So I bought the hazelnut again. This one smudges a little. Not bad. I bought the same product in onyx, and that one smudges so badly it's useless.

I was excited to try these after seeing the colors. Until I got them.After paying almost $20 I would like to think the product I received was new. However, what I was sent was the eyeliner out of the smashed box that had both ends opened and sent in a zip lock bag. The end was worn down some like it had been used or swatched. And there was a hair with a hair follicle on the end when I first opened it. Which is gross.I ordered 4 different colors and I do not see myself using them. 😕

the eyeliner fell apart after 1 month in use

Was looking for waterproof eyeliner but this one wasn’t waterproof for me. Goes on easily