One of Us Is Lying Hardcover – May 30, 2017

In "One of Us is Lying," Karen M. McManus crafts a thrilling contemporary mystery that invites readers to immerse themselves in the tension-filled corridors of Bayview High. Five seemingly typical students—each representing a different high school stereotype—walk into detention, but only four make it out alive. The shock of Simon's sudden death sets off a riveting chain of events, as the remaining classmates find themselves entwined in a web of suspicion and intrigue.Each of the four suspects—Bronwyn, Addy, Nate, and Cooper—harbors secrets that Simon was poised to expose, raising questions about their innocence and complicity. McManus skillfully interweaves multiple perspectives, allowing readers to uncover layers of deception and complexity within each character. As tensions rise and the investigation unfolds, the story explores themes of identity, loyalty, and the lengths one might go to protect their secrets.With its fast-paced narrative and clever plot twists, "One of Us is Lying" keeps readers guessing until the very end, delivering a gripping tale that challenges assumptions and highlights the darker side of high school life. Perfect for fans of mysteries and psychological thrillers, this book is an edge-of-your-seat read that reminds us that appearances can be deceiving—and that anyone can be capable of murder.

quick read, solid ya novel with romantic subplot. i was a little disappointed in the ending. i dont want to spoil it though so see for yourself. it is appropriate for 13+ readers. i would give it a solid 8/10. i am very dramatic so this book did have me putting it down, picking it back up, mouth open, shocked.

Fantastic! Kept me guessing to the very end! Very reminiscent of the breakfast club if you’re an 80s fan. Probably meant for younger generation but at 37, I enjoyed it too. Easy read with some adult topics. Really emphasizes what kids today go through. So glad my generation didn’t have social media when I was a teenager

One of Us Is Lying was is just outright one of the most addictive books I’ve read all year, if not longer. From the moment I picked it up and started reading I found it incredibly hard to put down; I read on my way to and from work, on my lunch hour, after dinner and right up until I could keep my eyes open no longer! One of Us Is Lying tells the story of five high school seniors; Gossip Girl-esque Simon who runs a gossip blog, popular baseball player Cooper, serious and studious Bronwyn, loveable drug dealer Nate and pretty girl Addy. Each one finds themselves suddenly in detention after having a cell phone mysteriously placed in each of their bags. Whilst trying to convince the supervising teacher that none of the phones belong to them and that someone must be pulling a prank, they all suddenly hear the sound of a crash outside. Whilst the teacher and four of the students rush to the window to see what is going on, one student, Simon, hangs back and when they all return to their seats Simon begins to choke. As Bronwyn, Nate, Cooper and Addy all try to get help for Simon, unfortunately, it arrives to late and he is pronounced dead at the hospital – from anaphylactic due to a peanut allergy.So who killed Simon? Well here is the tricky part. No one knows, but there are plenty of people who would want to. Simon has a lot of enemies due to his gossip blog that he runs, filled with the rumours and secrets of just about everyone in the school. But since he was in the room with just the others in detention, they quickly become the focus of the police investigation into Simon’s death and the ensuing media circus that threatens all of their reputations and futures.Each character bears the brunt of everyone’s judgement from both family and friends, is pressured to turn on the others and most importantly, has one last secret about themselves revealed on a tumblr blog which continues to post following Simon’s death.Who killed Simon? Who is still posting their secrets? Who wants them all to be destroyed? Who is lying?One of Us Is Lying takes you on a rollercoaster ride of some serious character development, highs and lows of emotion and an all-important final twist. It gave me a classic who-done-it scenario, all the of drama you would expect from a high school filled with rampant hormones, a newly budding romance, a secret romance and an incredibly satisfying finale. I would highly recommend this to anyone looking for a fast paced, addictive read, not to mention this is now set to become a tv series after being picked up by E!

One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus is an engaging, suspenseful mystery that keeps you hooked from the very first page. The story revolves around five high school students who walk into detention, but only four make it out alive. As the investigation unfolds, secrets start to emerge, and each character’s perspective adds depth and intrigue to the plot.I love how the author skillfully develops each of the main characters, making them feel real and relatable. The alternating points of view give readers insight into their thoughts and motivations, creating a complex web of suspense and drama. The book tackles important themes like bullying, secrets, and the pressure to conform, making it more than just a typical “whodunit” mystery.The twists and turns kept me guessing right until the end, and I enjoyed how the story combined elements of thriller, teen drama, and romance. If you’re a fan of fast-paced mysteries with great character development, One of Us Is Lying is definitely worth the read!

I read One of Us Is Lying a while back, and while the concept really grabbed me — five students go into detention, but only four come out alive — the book didn’t leave a lasting impression overall. It had potential, especially with the Breakfast Club-meets-murder-mystery vibe, but the suspense never fully pulled me in the way I hoped.The multiple POVs gave each character their moment, but the voices often blurred together. The mystery was interesting enough to keep reading, though I found parts of it predictable. That said, it touches on some heavier topics that added depth, which I appreciated.If you enjoy high school settings, messy secrets, and light mysteries with drama, this could be a hit for you. For me, it was a decent read, just not one that stuck with me.📚 I received no incentive for this review — just sharing honest thoughts from a longtime reader.