e.l.f.No Budge Shadow Stick, Longwear, Smudge-Proof Metallic Eyeshadow, Rich Amethyst, 0.056 Oz (1.6g)

This isn’t very waterproof. I put it on my top lids and it transfers up my eyes. Very disappointed and I looked like a clown

This eyeliner definitely isn't no budge. I looked like a panda just after a few hours where it had smudge around my eyes. Very disappointed and won't be using again shall go back to my usual eyeliner.

I bought this as it is meant to be waterproof, but I guess that doesn't mean it works for tightlining as it didn't stay put for a whole evening, let alone a day. Shame, as it's nice to use.

Disappointing. Whilst easy to apply and a string colour say after a few hours I looked like a panda with it definitely smudging. Would not buy again.

My favourite eye liner so far and I’ve tried all the quality brands but always had problems with sniffing and . Easy to put on and smudge and send to last all day. Will definitely buy again.