Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, 15Colors Eye Shadow Pencil, Pearl Eyeliner Kit Metallic Glitter Colored Eye liner for Women Eye&Lip Liner Professional Waterproof Eye Makeup

it’s so creamy the quality ♡ ahhh !!! it’s not really waterproof it washes off very easily but nice colorful set for i used these doing halloween ♡

These are the best water proof eyeliners I've ever bought. The colors are exactly like the pictures. Vibrant and long lasting

These liners are a good deal for the price, especially if you like darker shades. The red and brown go on smooth and show up well, but the lighter colors (like white and light pink) barely have any pigment. They’re creamy and easy to apply, but they smudge and don’t last very long—so you’ll need to reapply. Also, the packaging says “twist up,” but I couldn’t find a way to do that, which is frustrating. Overall, a nice set if you’re experimenting with makeup or mostly use deeper tones. Just don’t expect too much from the lighter shades or longevity.

This is a great deal for the money! Awesome colors and waterproof!

For the price, these are pretty good, but there is VERY little pigment. I had to press down painfully hard and line multiple times to get a cat eye look going. And then it smudged pretty quickly. The good news is that, the large number of blues lets you do an ombre technique pretty easily. I wish there were any warm colors in here, but maybe I just picked the wrong palette.

Love this, makes my eye look fun n colorful. Colors to match everything. I can use as lip liner too. Love all the colors

Grand daughters loved this. I bought for 7-8 year old little soon but they had so much fun playing dress-up with these and they work perfect. Colors are bright and work well

They advertise that the pencils are waterproof, smudge proof, and shelf sharpening. They are none of those things. The colors are nice but I only purchased this brand because of the claim to be waterproof, smudge proof, and shelf sharpening. I do not recommend purchasing if waterproof, smudge proof, and shelf sharpening is important to you. Please change your advertisement.