GigaBite Single Ingredient All Natural Free Range Bully Treats and Chews - Bully Sticks/Bladder Sticks/Beef Esophagus by Best Pet Supplies - Bully Sticks (Half-cut 6"), Pack of 10

I always buy my bully sticks from Best Pet Supplies because they are a great value and odor free* (*rarely, I get a stick that has a slight odor, but overall, they are odor-free). I know people are always looking for the thickets sticks, especially for those of us who have big, big dogs with strong teeth. My puppy (10 months old) is almost 80 pounds (oh no!!!), and so I really want the thickest ones. The BPS bully sticks come in so many different packs, I have now memorized the product code of the thickest ones. This one is NOT it. The size is good, but the thickest ones are PB-12-V-LB. See below for summary and photos for comparison.For reference, if you want:-12" bully sticks that are thick, but not super thick, get the PB-12-10 (10 sticks per pack)-12" bully sticks that are THICK and truly a "gigabite", get the PB-12-V-LB (there are fewer sticks/pack, usually 6-7 per pack, but sell for $5 cheaper than the 10 pack)Overall, they are a great value and far cheaper than buying them in the pet store. Hope this helps!

Great item - my Golden Doodle loved these

These were my go- to bully sticks for a long time. Nice size, limited smell, long lasting. I knocked off a star because my last bag smelled bad and they were MUCH thinner than usual- like stringy twigs. I've noticed most brands will eventually send out a bad batch like this. I might try them again and the future if I don't find anything better

My dog is over the top obsessed with these bones, and ONLY these bones!!I have purchased similar/comparable high quality bones from both Petsmart, Petco, etc... she won’t even touch those ones. But these.. she carries them around the house and chews on them all day, everyday!!It’s important to note that she is a really picky eater... I have to mix her dog food with other goodies to get her to eat anything, and only high quality kibble. So these bones must really be good!I love that there is no odor to them, and it does take her awhile to finish off 1 entire bone. I usually take them away to pace her, but if I didn’t she’d probably go thru 1 entire bone in 1-2 days.I do agree that the thicknesses of each bone within the bag does very.. there are some that are noticeably different in size (thickness). But I’ve never noticed one to be unreasonably too thin. But also, my dog is a 10lb terrier mix so she’s smaller.I have reordered these exact bones approx 5 times now, and I will continue to do so because my dog really loves them!!

My dog gets excited for these long lasting natural chews

Not worth the money. I was swayed by the reviews but the bully sticks are so thin and easy to break. My dog who is a slow chewer finished this in half the time she normally would with other name brands and this brand is about the same price as those. I was pretty disappointed.

My dog loves these! He’s a yorkie so he can chew on them and not something else.

I give 2 stars instead of 1 because both of our pups like these bully sticks. What kind of dog doesn’t? Well, our 4 year old male doberman didn’t until he saw her baby sister enjoying one. He prefers rawhide products because he is a shredder. This product does attract both of our pups and odor is minimal.My poor review is mainly due to the inconsistency in the quality/size/thickness/weight.When I found 2 thin pieces in the first bag, just like the one in the images I provided, I said “Meh, you get what you pay for.” And let it slide. I bought the regular, 6 inch x 10 Pcs bag for $20 as a starter. Wasn’t prepared to pay more for something my pups may not like. Both of our dogs are large breeds but I prefer to give them 6 inch sticks instead of 12 because one is adult, male and a shredder and the other is a puppy, female and a biter/chewer. His destruction speed is significantly faster than her and the adult finished the thick piece in 20 minutes while it takes a lot longer for the puppy. She often drops it and walks away to find something more entertaining. In the last 6 months we learned that the 12 inch ones cause more commotion between the 2 dogs because they trade their sticks so many times in between chewing and sometimes I guess there are discrepancies? So 6 inch ones work perfect for all of us. We have purchased 3 bags in the last 3 weeks and the bag that just arrived today have 4 of the very thin ones. Took literally 2 minutes for our adult pup to snap it in half, he didn’t even drop it, just kept the whole thing in his mouth while chewing and swallowed it. 2 minutes flat. That’s when my inner Karen told me to whip out my digital kitchen scale. The thickest one weighed 1.5 oz, this was just one piece. 5 of them were 0.7-0.8 oz. The rest... 0.4-0.5 oz.Will their jumbo ones work better? Maybe. But how many of those thin ones am I going to find in the jumbo bags? The product image is so deceiving. Only 1 out of 10 pieces looked like them. I’m not buying any more. Would rather pay $60 for something with better quality control than 3 x $20 bags of this.