JISONCASEJS-APL-01K10 Case Black

Great little case. Not too tight at all as some reviewers have pointed out. I like that I can put top cover behind or over top of end to provide easy in/out or keep it more securely. I keep in my briefcase or pouch so not too worried about it falling out. leather is soft, not too tight. Overall: good price and highly recommended.

First of all, 2 separate designs under a single Amazon listing is annoying. I'm not talking about different colors of an item… I mean COMPLETELY different design. It may be common practice, but it's frequently misleading.One version of the case has an elastic strap and an open end which allows the pencil to possibly fall out and the removable cap to possibly get lost. The other version they call the "Smile" case which covers the cap end of the Apple Pencil but HAS NO ELASTIC STRAP.The only reason I went ahead and bought the "Smile" version is because 2 separate answers to questions about the case say that, even though it doesn't show in pictures, it has a black elastic strip. This is INCORRECT. (See pics)If you want a good Apple Pencil holder that holds the whole pencil instead of leaving an inch exposed AND has an elastic strap, look elsewhere.

Excellent product.....good quality, right price

Nice fit for the apple pencil.

easy to use, keeps the pen save and the cap from getting lost when you charge it. Well made. I only wish it had a velcro on the case so I could attach it to the iPad pro keyboard cover

Fit like a glove

I guess it's fine. I think the leather is artificial but overall the piece looks nice.

very nicely made, super thin, holds cap in place, opening slit is long enough so pencil can be removed by gripping the pencil body - and not just by the cap, which is the problem with most of the other sleeve designs.