Pierce And Fine Graphic Pen

I love this eyeliner! It stays all day with minimal-no smudging and goes on well.

Easy to control and doesn’t smear or bleed. Easiest I’ve found so far to do a winged eye. The only negative is is runs out more quickly than beauty store brands.

I got this eyeliner in an Ipsy bag or something back in 2018- I’ve been using it since 2018 and it’s now Feb 2024. Gross, I know…but it’s the best eye liner and I couldn’t part with it. It only just started drying out this month. I finally found it here on Amazon and it’s just as good as the first one I got in 2018. Idk any eyeliner that’s ever lasted 6 years before, but this one did. It goes on so smooth and so deeply black. It’s perfect for winged liner!! I’ve always been the eyeliner friend. Everyone always wanted me to do their eyeliner bc I was so good at doing a cat eye. I’ll never use a different liner. This one is by far THE BEST.

Great for wings. Easy peasy

I love this eyeliner. With lash extensions one can’t use an oily based cleanser as it disrupts the strength of the glue. So one needs a liner that can wash off easily, most I’ve tried flake, fade or wear off. Not this one. It stays on like white on rice but washes off like a breeze.

I received this eyeliner in a subscription box and it was amazing and lasted a really long time. This one arrived pretty dried up and only lasted a few weeks. I ordered again, thinking it was a one-off and the same thing happened. By from the manufacturer.

This was advertised as waterproof yet at the touch of any moisture, it runs. Even after applying powder and a setting spray, this eyeliner smeared all over my lower eyes. I simply could not get this to stay on. Worse liquid eyeliner ever. At this price I would get something else. Or even a pencil liner, at least those stays on my eyes.

This is a great liner!!! This one came like it had been sitting, packaged, too long. It was somewhat already dried up 🥺🥺🥺