stila Smudge Kajal Eye Liner, Intense Black

I really like this product! I’ve always love Stella but I have appreciated their eyeliner is the most it is dark it is creamy it is bold I love it

The tip breaks so easily, I barely have the pencil past the end where it comes out.

So I have been looking for a good waterproof eyeliner to last all day on my bottom water line (wishful thinking, I know). This was the one that kept coming up among you tubers (some of the best in the makeup industry) as one that would not move, unfortunately for me my $8 L’Oréal infallible carbon black lasts twice as long and is twice as dark! I would give this one star if it wasn’t for the nice packaging and easy to use dispenser. So it’s back to the drawing board and that is the last time I spend $20 on eyeliner!

Beautiful glide on liner. Smudge or leave thick dark line. Does a pretty cat eye.

Awesome in the water line. No smudging after it sets and doesn't collect in the tear duct or cause panda eyes on the outer edge.

I love this eyeliner. It's super dark.

Awful eyeliner! Does not go on smoothly, blotchy, smears, ends up in corner of eyes... throwing it away

Disappointed. YouTuber Tati recommendation this, and as a fellow contact wearer, I was excited to finally find a liner that doesn’t react to my (semi) watery eyes. Nope.. definitely had build up in the corner of my eyes within an hour of wear. *only worn on bottom lash line/tear line.