Beauty BakerieLollipop Liquid Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Pen with Felt Tip Brush for Precise Eye Makeup, Waterproof Eyeliner for All Day Wear, 3.5mL, Jet Black

This is the most intense eyeliner i’ve ever used. When it says smudge proof it’s not exaggerating. i applied this on a Friday before a camping trip and clocked into work on Monday morning and it hadn’t flaked, smudged, or smeared. It doesn’t cause my lash extensions to stick together and I didn’t notice any excess shedding from the use of this either. This liner is unmatched. buy it.

So I've used beauty Bakerie eyeliner for well over a year now, but I usually purchase through like ulta. I purchased through Amazon because I could get it delivered within like 2 days in time for an event filled weekend, however this is either super old product or maybe it was stored incorrectly before shipping. My second use I'm already having a hard time with product pigment and it was difficult to get a consistent line without having to go over again to keep it from being patchy. The tips of the wings I was trying are also not crisp and clean, there just isn't enough product coming out. Buyer beware!

Amazing product. Lasts long and is hard to smear. Super nice firm pointed tip

try the benefit eyeliner in the red packaging. the best ive used yet, over pat mcgrath and stella.

This liquid eyeliner cost so much money and it still fades and smears. I used it once to see what all the hype was and its all bs. the best liquid eyeliner is made my milani and unfortunately they no longer sell it. if i can get a refund for this eyeliner i would.

I wish it hadn't flaked off because I had high hopes.

This eyeliner lasts through a full day or work in the 90° heat and is super easy to apply.

I’ve been on the hunt for a good eyeliner pen that can stand up to oily skin and humid weather.This. Is. It.Everything I love:- sturdy pen tip, not flimsy or prone to fraying like some- clean, matte line- easy to draw wings because of the shape- smudge proof, as promisedWill definitely be purchasing again :)

I have gone through many liquid eyeliners but always ended up with smudges above and below the wings. I use lots of face cream and moisturiser so my skin is left a bit oily which never helps the eyeliner, plus whenever I yawn I tear up and this messed with the eyeliner - every hour at work I was having to wipe away smudges. After a few seconds to let dry, this eyeliner stays put. Went to work today with this on and minimal smudges during the day, literally the tiniest of smudges all day. Very impressed. Seems to come off with gentle washing with water and soap.