20 PCS Colored Eyeliners Pencil Set, Retractable Matte Colorful Eyeliner

These really are good! The product is bright, the colors clear, and it stays put. Doesn’t smudge or blur after it dries, and colors can be layered, but will not blend. It’s long lasting too, and definitely waterproof. Moreover, the felt brush tip features a long taper, making it super easy to control thickness during application, and making it versatile for more than just simple eyeliner, as more dramatic looks are also possible :3

If you’re looking for a liquid eyeliner kit that can stand up to your wildest (and sweatiest) pride makeup dreams, then LOOK NO FURTHER! I just used this fabulous set to create some epic pride flag flowers on my face, and WOW, I am so impressed! First off, the application was a breeze. The liquid went on smooth as silk, and the colors? Vibrant doesn’t even cover it—these are bold, electric, and absolutely gorgeous! No weird chemical smell either, which is always a plus when you’re doing your art. And get this: I wore it for OVER 8 HOURS in 80-degree heat, sweating like crazy at an outdoor event. It didn’t crack, fade, or move an inch. But here’s where it gets really impressive—it survived a full round of vigorous... ahem, husband-related activities. 😅 From being smashed into pillows to sweaty close-ups, this eyeliner stayed PERFECT. No smudging, no fading, nothing—just flawless, vibrant pride colors still shining through! After all that action, it was super easy to take off with my regular face wash, no staining or leftover marks. Seriously, this stuff came off like a dream. For someone as pale as me, I was worried about staining, but there was none of that. 10/10, would absolutely recommend this eyeliner kit! Whether you’re rocking pride makeup, getting creative with face paint, or just want something that can stand the test of time and sweat, this is your go-to. Go grab it—you won’t regret it! ✨

These are twist-up pencils and have really good pigmentation and really beautiful colors. They never "dried" or "set" for me, though, and rubbed/wore/smudged right off within an hour. Not sure how they are supposed to be "long lasting." Maybe fun just to play with colors, they are certainly an excellent value for the price. I wouldn't expect them to wear for more than 30 mins, though.

Worked well for pride looks and fun colorful looks. You get what you pay for and sometimes they werent the easiest to work with but overall worked well! With good setting spray it has great longevity and water resistance. The texture could be creamier for some colors. Removed fully but took some work.

I love the bright colors! However, they are a bit too sft & creamy & require & very light hand in application. Smudges EASILY. I also noticed the color fades significantly throughout the day. I use them just as lid liners & pair with highliter & eyeshadow. Makes for some beautiful results & for the price I'm pretty happy. Oh, the white kinda sucks though... it's not opaque enough. The photo I provided is just a quick color swatching I did upon unboxing & in no way represents my abilities or style! 🤣

I only use a few of the colors because I don’t experiment much, but the ones I do use immediately replaced all of pencils I have from major makeup companies. Precise, long lasting. Takes one second to draw a clean line and decide for yourself how thick of a line you want to create.

I absolutely love these liquid eyeliners! The pigmentation is amazing! one swipe gives a bold, rich color without needing to go over it multiple times. The tip is perfect for creating precise lines. Best of all, they don’t smudge or fade throughout the day, even after hours of wear. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a high-quality, long-lasting liquid eyeliner!

good but some colors are way lighter