Newhouse Hardware BR5W-10 Unlighted Doorstep Button, 10-Pack, Brass

Plastic material but finish is holding up. Easy to wire up. Only issue is the light burned out. Haven't taken it apart to see if it has a bulb to replace. Still okay for the price.

Perfect fit and works excellent for its intended purpose. So easy to install too. YOU won't be Sorry

Looks wonderful, great replacement for the old timer like me.

Easy to break during installation, you have to separate the tiny peace that carries the 2 screws before unscrewing otherwise it will break, I broke it and used super glue to fix it, I think manufacturer should have provided a clear warning to install this button

Maybe something was fundamentally changed in the design or manufacture of these doorbell buttons but I honestly don't see what the negative reviewers were complaining about. In fact I was a little psyched out by those reviews and was mentally prepping myself for a frustrating installation. First, it arrived earlier than promised - kudos Amazon. The wire screws were NOT difficult to loosen at all. I used a flat slotted screwdriver instead of philips if that matters. Based on other reviews, I was bracing for the whole thing to fall apart in my hands creating a frustrating little job putting the puzzle back together. NOTHING like that happened. The button lit up right away. A couple of test pushes confirmed the button doing was it's job. Gently bent the fins that hold it in place in the tube in the stucco so that I could more easily push it into the wall. The whole installation was completed in well under 5 minutes. It literally took me longer to write this review than it did to install this doorbell button. My only very minor ding is that the goldtone collar has a very shiny finish and as a result it looks a little cheap. Just like the one I was replacing.