essence BYE BYE PANDA EYES! SMUDGE-PROOF VOLUMIZING AND DEFINING MASCARA, longlasting, volumizing, defining, natural (16ml)

Ordered this after a review saying this was a tubing mascara. Which is what I'm looking for. This was perfect. Short bristles that don't reach my eyelid, just the lashes. No clumping. I will need to curl my lashes first next time. There was no smudging!! Very often I forget I've just put mascara on, close my eyes and end up with a black smudge under my eyes. I was feeling confident, so I covered my bottom lashes, too. Then, the ultimate test - to go out on a hot day and see if it stayed in place. Yes it did. My ultra sensitive eyes weren't affected, either. In the evening, I gently washed it off with warm water on a facecloth. In future, I will pre-curl my lashes to get them more noticeable. There is no major volume with this mascara, but is perfect for not irritating sensitive eyes, or washing off in a menopausal hot flush. I'm very happy.

its very good on sensitive eyes, and doesn't clump too much. it comes off very easily and dries quickly, making it a great on the go mascara also. it gets a little crusty and clumpy after a while but overall a great product and cheap too!

I’ve lost count of how many “smudge proof” mascaras i’ve bought over the years only to look in the mirror half way through the day to see a goth staring back at me (nothing wrong with goths but not the look I'm going for). The tubing mascaras work really well but they're also expensive, so thought id give this a go. My hopes were not high, but this mascara is the real deal; it goes on really nicely, not clumpy, looks natural, and most importantly - it does not smudge!! I haven't stress tested it in warm weather or during exercise yet, but so far so good. For this price you need to give it a go.

The wand is ergonomic but the mascara doesn't meet my needs.

best smudge proof

This mascara will do the following ( and ONLY that): NOTHING. It will not lenghten, thicken, it will not be smudge proof, …it is actually hard to think of ONE positive attribute one could bestow on it. No, wait, it’s cheap. But you might as well take the equivalent money and throw that in the bin. Because you will do that with this mascara. Avoid. I hate leaving bad reviews but this product is singularly useless.

It does exactly what it says no panda eyes fells light on the eyes no smudges looks so natural would recommend good value for money

I've got super fat eyelids so anything on my eyes turns in to a splodgey mess within an hour. Other claim to be waterproof, yes. But tubby eyelid proof? No. Found this. What a result. Tiniest bit of smudging by the end of the day, but that is a huge win for me! They don't give the biggest lashes, so that's a little sucky. But it's a price I'm willing to pay. Hard to find these elsewhere. Wondering if they've stopped making them? I shall stock up!

Product arrived safely earlier than estimated, and honestly this mascara will save my lashes from the aggressive rubbing. Get y'all some tubing mascara asap!!!

Bon mascara, tient bien toute la journée et facile à enlever le soir

Cumple! No mancha

I have no idea if this mascara flakes or runs, because when I apply it, it doesn’t look like I’m wearing mascara at all, so I am forced to use a different mascara over the top. I have very fair lashes, so it’s odd to me that a black mascara would barely show up on my lashes. Maybe the tube is actually empty? who knows?!

Love this mascara! It doesn’t smudge at all. Really holds its own against the more expensive brands!